How to read a court decision: a short guide
Court decisions seem to be written for lawyers. In fact they have a clear structure, and the key points can be found in a few minutes.

The texts of Ukrainian court decisions are published in an open register. To avoid getting lost in several pages of legal language, it is enough to know which parts the document consists of.
The four parts of a decision
- Introductory. The date, the court, the panel of judges, the case number, the parties. Take the exact details for citation from here. 2. Descriptive. Who demanded what and what the other side disputed. This is a summary of positions, not the court’s findings. 3. Reasoning. What circumstances the court established, what evidence it accepted and what legal provisions it applied. This is where the answer to “why” is. 4. Operative. What exactly the court decided. It begins with the words “decided,” “ruled” or “resolved.” If you are short of time, read it first.
What to pay attention to
- Case number. It lets you find all decisions in the case, from the first instance to cassation.
- Type of proceedings. Criminal, civil, commercial, administrative: both the rules and the time limits depend on it.
- Whether the decision has entered into force. First-instance decisions can be appealed. While an appeal is under way, the decision is not final.
- Anonymization. In the register, people’s names are replaced with “PERSON_1,” “PERSON_2.” The names of companies and institutions, and job titles, usually remain.
Three instances
A case is first heard by a court of first instance. Its decision can be challenged on appeal, and then in cassation at the Supreme Court. High-level corruption cases are heard by the High Anti-Corruption Court (HACC).
Common mistakes in court news
- Calling a person guilty before a verdict that has entered into force.
- Confusing pre-trial restraint with punishment: pre-trial detention or bail is not a sentence.
- Writing “the court acquitted” when the case was closed on procedural grounds.
- Retelling one side’s position as an established fact.


